Then please delete, gentlemen, no hard feelings, but before you do, please read the following and ponder before dropping these compilation threads in the trash can:
Be advised that you're the first and only forum to take such a stance (not even Total War Center cared about that - on the contrary admins thanked me for pulling it all together - probably since it's just a member sharing pictures, like everyone else does, not a site-official gallery embedded into the site structure), and I am sure any of the worries leading to deletion are completely unnecessary and possibly unfounded. I also have good reason to suspect that any hypothetical IP troubles (unlikely to arise in the first place) will arise in the initial form of a request to take down one or more specific pictures, whose url adresses would be provided by whoever requests takedown, and thus be easy for me, or a moderator, to click edit, enter search/find, and delete, for those particular image takedown requests (or just delete the whole thread if that is more convenient). It will not be a flat-out lawsuit without prior warning, there is always to be a cease & desist warning first in these matters. So even if one is to take an IP view of things, the most practical stance would be let-it-happen, we'll take down any individual pictures requested for takedown when and if we get there, no worries. In the meanwhile, hobbyists and historically interested people might get some use out of the compiled images. The only time I've heard of anything relating to troubles for sharing images, was when GW artwork was shared over on Chaos Dwarfs Online in their CD artwork compilation, and GW lawyers asked CDO to take them down, which CDO did, no lawsuit filed, and that's the end of it, no harm done.
With that noted, on to the circumstances for this year's image salvage:
The source of it all is
the Photobucket crisis, and the devastating restructuring of Imageshack prior to that (which made us lose lots of shared hobby goodness in one fell swoop without prior warning - at least Photobucket played fairer) plus some smaller album sites/photohosting sites disappearing. Brilliant conversions, paintjobs, concept sketches and artwork shared via those platforms were gone with the wind. With Photobucket we had a kind of warning, so time was of the essence. Let's just say that I've never worked as hard as during this year's summer, primarily with salvaging Chaos Dwarf pictures and artworks of sufficient quality or ingenuity to be worth salvaging, all voluntarily and unpaid, of course.
Here is the full register of image salvage compilations, which I've also posted on those forums I know of which might be interested in it (and with fantasy based in history, that includes all Warhammer fantasy forums), and which do not have a choking picture limit. I think you'll find a sample of each of these compilations on Oldhammer in General Discussion, since this site gratefully don't sport a picture limit to speak of (a point in your favour!). This is just as with the sharing of tutorials over in the hobby section; the important thing is sharing these resources, not whoever made them (I made all my own tutorials which I've posted, but everyone and their grandmother is welcome to share them willy-nilly without asking for permission or namedropping me; the more widespread, the better). Sources of inspiration, of use for as many people as possible.
We presently have an easily available treasure of images (and information, but that's not as endangered) for anyone with an inclination to learning who knows how to use a searchfield. Yet as Photobucket, Imageshack and the like shows, this digital treasure trove is flimsy and vulnerable. I've come to realize that we might well be living in the great time of free sharing of knowledge and artworks (free in every sense of the word, all positive), and there are no guarantees all these image hoards will be available freely, for free, for everyone to view and be inspired by, in the future. Backup copies are needed in case anything crashes, otherwise it's like letting great art die out from public view.
The last thing in the world I'd do is to play up to modern IP mania, which I as a thinking and creative person view with scorn. In short, getting inspired by the works of others is pivotal to human creativity and has been so since time immemorial, and putting artificial shackles and limits on creativity, as has become the legal fashion of our age, is unwise, and better underlined with swearwords if one is so inclined. I'm concerned with the treasure of images available for public viewing for thinking people and artists and hobbyists, that we currently have easily available at our fingertips, an astounding resource. This is not a paid job, so I've undertaken the image salvage methodically, and discarded aspects such as source-referencing to speed up the process and make it at all humanely possible and not a hardship. Not a paid vocation, as mentioned, just something I do every now and then in my spare time between a multitude of other projects (mainly sculpting for casting). Working round the clock here, but have found a way to do so without wearing myself out easily. To start hunting sources, backtracking image searches and referencing them would be anathema to this humane way of voluntary desktop work, so it's out of the question.
You'll notice that the sources for many of the Deviantart-salvaged Lotr Dwarf images I've collected and shared are referenced, but that is only because there are so few non-Weta Workshop Lotr Dwarf concept artworks which are not produced by only three productive artists. So here it was easier to organize them by artist's name.
What is to be salvaged? The answer is quality illustrations worth preserving, by assorted artists, none mentioned, none forgotten, as many good artworks backed-up as fast as possible. Many of the images were originally shared in such a manner that the artist's name or even the subject of the artwork wasn't mentioned, and in these cases often the artist wasn't recognizable (I've come to recognize a dozen or more, including Giuseppe Rava and Angus McBride), and sometimes even didn't sport a signature. I'd have preferred for every artwork to be adorned with a signature, but what can one do about it? So due credit given, so to speak, is by itself given in the case of those images where the artist himself included a signature in the artwork. None mentioned, none forgotten. The sorting system has been to file the images under theme (e.g. Scythian civilian life or Assyrian siege), not source name.
As of presently anyone can repeat this image salvage by using a plethora of searchword variations (requires some detailed knowledge of history or fantasy settings) on Google Images primarily, but also
Deviantart (a nightmare to trawl through longer searches),
Artstation and
Pinterest. As for Pinterest being mentioned in a way as though it would be suspect to salvage images from there, I am nonplussed. Whatever that site is, it certainly isn't a repository exclusively for original work. If one, e.g. types in "Chaos Dwarf artwork" into Pinterest's searchfield, you'll come upon a plethora of images. Many of them will be official GW/FW/license holder artwork pieces, and others will be pieces taken from such sites as Deviantart (with or without mentioning the artist), while other results will be painted miniatures and conversions taken from Chaos Dwarfs Online, Cool Mini Or Not etc. In other words, taken from all over the place.
This whole image salvage is taken from all over the place. For interested people's benefit, and to save artworks for public viewing in some manner. History informs fantasy, and inspiration begets creativity.
My advice is let it be, delete if any ruckus would pop up but do not delete preemptively, and let the compilations stand for people to stumble across and be inspired by.
Cheers,
Matte / KNC